NAS (Network Attached Storage) vs. Cloud: What to Choose?

Updated July 2020

I guess, your photos are the ones responsible for making this question acute. These are the most precious and space-consuming files you have. And today we don’t want just to store them somewhere safely (like on a bunch of DVDs or an external hard drive). We want to store keep them connected. That’s basically the reason our new heroes today are Cloud and NAS. I bet you know they both will work perfectly for the connected digital asset management solution Pics.io we’re working on. But, still, which one to choose today?

Choosing the storage: Apples vs. oranges

Before we dive any further, we need to clarify the terms. While with Cloud, everything is pretty simple (actually most of us are or were Google Drive users at some point of time), the question remains: what is NAS?

The answer is hidden in the abbreviation. Network Attached Storage refers to a network/internet connected device (a sort of small computer) placed in your home or office and used to store your data. Once connected to your WiFi router or network, NAS is accessible from anywhere (the same as with Cloud) provided you have a password and username.

So if to compare two solutions, what’s better?

Meme Apple vs. Oranges

Actually, it’s not a 100% fair comparison. It’s more like apples and oranges. If your priority is safety, cloud storage and a local single drive backup might be the best (but not the cheapest) choice. NAS, in turn, offers increased storage and space (being in one network).

Let’s make things clear. Cloud storage is renting up space from a provider. You can imagine it as renting space in several NAS devices standing somewhere in the world.

In its turn, Network Attached Storage provides a space for the whole local network and usually finds its place in your dorm room. With the ability to store and share data most NAS devices can also run as servers (for your website, FTP or else) and support as multimedia servers, considering UPnP and DLNA in particular.

Thrifty guys and girls would argue that it’s not necessary to buy a NAS for the task. They would say you just need some old computer, get an external hard drive for like $50, install something like OwnCloud on it and be happy. Short (read as “cheapest”) way isn’t the best option, as you might guess. If you want a similar experience you have with the cloud I still recommend using a specialized network storage device. It will be less frustrating in setup and everyday usage, trust me.

Ok, now let’s compare Cloud storage and NAS. There are pros and cons in both cases, by the way.

NAS vs. Cloud Storage
Storage Your storage capacity is unlimited as long as you’re willing to pay for more space. But as compared to the cloud, NAS gives you more storage for the same cost.
NAS 1-0 Cloud
Access You have quick and easy access to your files from both. Regardless of the solution you choose, your performance depends on the speed of your internet connection as well as the amount of data you store. Still NAS usually grants you more options for access like more advanced apps, Smart TV, or consoles.
NAS 2-0 Cloud
File sharing Sharing doesn't truly differ in both cases: you can provide direct file and/or folder access & stream your media over the internet.
NAS 3-1 Cloud
Other features By no means, cloud services grant you more functionality: file and image editing, scanning your documents, or working offline. NAS features are more down to earth and reduce to standard sharing & access, plus setting users’ rights and permissions.
NAS 3-2 Cloud
Performance As said, your internet speed is the main factor here. Still NAS usually needs more time for setup, and it includes everything, from simple installation to RAID configuration. Cloud, in turn, will let you go inside in a few seconds. On the flip side, many cloud service apps won’t use the maximum possible bandwidth. NAS, in turn, has a direct connection to your device, and the upload time is likely to be shorter.
NAS 4-3 Cloud
Security Security is another controversial criterion when choosing between NAS and cloud storage. With the cloud, the third party takes responsibility for your data. So NAS seems more attractive by this logic. You can also set up a RAID on your NAS (which makes two copies of each file) for better security. Modern cloud services, in turn, like Google Drive or Dropbox offer you exclusive security measures encrypting your data and storing them in reliable data centers. Additionally, you can set up two-factor authentication when logging in to the cloud.
NAS 5-4 Cloud
Reliability & Backup The difference between NAS and cloud lies in on-site vs. off-site backup, and each has its own pros and cons. A built-in solution for backup (on-site) means backups happen automatically and faster. Still it’s less reliable, and you’ll lose your data if any disaster happens (a theft or hard drive failure, for example). If you use cloud off-site backup, there is little you have to worry about. Your data will be safe whatever happens. The only thing you have to take care of is your internet provider to obtain a fast-speed internet connection.
NAS 5-5 Cloud
Ease of use In recent years, NAS devices have become more user-friendly and consumer-oriented. Still this product counts more on tech-savvy users, and NAS cannot compete with the cloud in its ease of use. As compared to NAS, cloud services are more intuitive and have all the variety of desktop and mobile apps.
NAS 5-6 Cloud
Cost Nowadays you can find NAS and cloud storage for any budget. But NAS still remains a cheaper solution as long-term storage. We’ll discuss this factor in detail below.
NAS 6-6 Cloud

As you see, both solutions are worth your attention. It all depends on your specific preferences and needs. But now we’ll consider a purely economical side in this dilemma. Let’s start!

How soon will NAS pay off?

Ok, I invest money into a server, hard drives… how soon that investment will be returned as compared to the scenario when I use a cloud service like Google Drive or Dropbox? For simplicity, let’s leave the setup (which is sometimes overwhelming for the non-geeks) out of the brackets. I also eliminated the Internet connection fee because it will vary depending on the use case (if you often work with files remotely then you’ll probably gonna need a better upload speed, i.e. spend additional $10–20/month for a faster connection).

Test #1. Cheap NAS vs. Google Drive

Here I assumed that you’ve chosen some D-Link NAS ($175) and a pair of 1Tb HDDs to make RAID 1 (each $67). Note: It’s not feasible to take less capacious drives today. In fact, even less than 2Tb.

Electricity. Its average power consumption is around 10 Watts/hour, so it will cost you $1.5/month. So if we use NAS our initial expenses are $309 and each month we pay $1.5. Good. Cloud on the other hand has a variety of options and you can buy as little as 100Gb. As you might guess the pay off time will depend on the storage space you actually need. And here’s how it changes:

Pricing

Since Google now gives 15Gb for free, it’s obvious that NAS will never pay off if 15Gb is enough for you. The situation changes as your appetite grows. Note: the payoff period of 3 years or longer is a flop. It’s long enough to expect price reductions in Google Drive and there’s a good chance something wrong might happen to your hard drive. The table shows that cloud is the best option if your photo archive is up to 1TB. And, actually, that applies to the majority of photographers. However, Google has a pretty big tier from 1TB all the way to the 10TB (so both 10001Gb and 10TB will cost you $100/month).

Test #2. High-end NAS vs. Google Drive

I assume that many people reading this post won’t be satisfied with a cheap NAS. They want a robust device with extendable functionality and really enterprise-level performance. I know what you’re thinking. Synology has those things in their product line. This table represents how the situation changes when you purchase a better NAS device (Synology DiskStation DS1513+ for $800, for example).

Pricing if NAS device was added

As you can see renting stuff is much cheaper than owning, at least when it comes to storage space. With high-end NAS storing less than 1TB is economically stupid.

Test #3. NAS vs. MEGA

Google Drive isn’t the only option in the field. In fact, it's not even an optimal one when it comes to big numbers. There is a game-changer service and it is called MEGA (service by Megaupload founder). Check out their pricing:

MEGA Pricing

Not only does it offer insane 50Gb for free, but the increase in price is much more subtle. Here’s a very descriptive chart:

GDrive and MEGA comparison

With such reasonable pricing, MEGA can be viable even after 1TB tier.

Pricing

And now the bottom line

Well, though you already have a great offer from cloud storage providers, when it comes to large volumes of data there is nothing better than Network Attached Storage. It has also other benefits some people will find valuable. Anyway, the cloud is already extremely close, and, perhaps, one might find that its higher cost is fully compensated by multiple features and ease. Hope, this chart will help you to make the right decision.

Cloud vs. NAS: Optimal choice depending on the capacity you need

If you have chosen Google Drive as your storage, the smartest next step is to find the solution to get your files organized within this storage. We at Pics.io are here to help. Subscribe for our 14-day FREE trial to find whether our solution fits your business needs.

Pics.io Pro-level photo editing in a browser
Pics.io Team
Welcome to Pics.io blog, where you'll get useful tips, resources & best practices on how digital asset management can help your business to manage & distribute digital content on top of cloud storage.
USA